Columbus, Ohio
12.5K views 4 comments
Not resolved

Geico raised my rates after a fender bender, so I cancelled my Geico auto insurance policy in June by telephone because I received a lower rate from another company and bought other insurance.Then, two months later, I received a bill from Geico claiming that I had not paid my bill since June.

When I called to complain, they said there was no record of my cancellation and told me to fax proof that I had insurance through another company since June. The next day, I faxed the other company's declaration sheets, dated from June on all three of my vehicles. One month later, again received the same bill from Geico, threatening action unless I faxed or mailed the same information I had already provided. This time, I send the declaration sheets via Certified Mail with Return Receipt.

One month later, I again received a bill from Geico asking for faxed/mailed proof and this time, they threatened to ruin my credit record. After already wasting time and money via faxes and Certified Mail, my insurance agent had to call them in-person to try and put an end to this fiasco.

That was two weeks ago, and I haven't received anything else yet.The next steps would be Better Business Bureau, Attorney General's office and letter to my congressman/senator.

Review about: Geico Auto Insurance.

Had an Experience with Geico?

Write a review


Comment as anonymous or
Terms of Service
Post Comment

GEICO is charging $99 as cancellation fee, which was not mentioned while taking the policy.I had queried the same while taking the policy and I was told, there will be no fee.

Initially they charged me $800.After lot of arguments, they re-calculated to $99.


Found better rates and switched to another insurance company and GEICO charged me $91.30 cancellation fee. Never recommend this company anyone


When I cancelled, they threatened me with reporting to the DMV that I had no insurance.They are *** of the earth!

Trying to blackmail me just because I couldn't afford a car and was using public transportation.

I don't have to prove ANYTHING to them.They may have made an illegal deal with the government to force everyone to buy their product but I certainly don't have to take their 'orders'.


I tried cancelling Geico with same issues.When I first called to cancel, they sound like a used car sales man trying to keep me with a policy that is $60 more a month.

He was extremely pushy and brought back flashbacks of AOL in the days.I have learned to never use them again in the future!

You May Also Like

Geico customer service is non-existent.  Geico "My wife, who has Geico Insurance, was rear ended by a driver that reported having Geico Insurance. The other driver was listed on the police report as at fault..." Read more Geico doesn't know what customer service means.  Geico loves to put obstacles in your way.  Geico "My wife was rear ended on the I-270 about a month ago, and the person who hit her flat out said it was his fault. His insurance was Geico...." Read more Geico - Measly $20 Geico "HEADS UP EVERYONE- I used to love GEICO to bits. I've been with them for 5 years and I have perfect payment history. They're unable to waive measly $20 insufficient..." Read more
Geico Medical Claim Review from Birmingham, Alabama Geico "Back on September 9, 2015 I was hit head on by a gecio insurance customer. Here it is 11 months later my medical bills haven't been paid, my..." Read more Camping World - Up sold dishonest protection plan Camping World "Camping World uses Microtech Chemicals for their interior protection plan. I wrote a review on July 4th and here's the update. We paid $1200 for the interior protection plan. Microtech..." Read more Certplex Actualtests - Unlimited access Certplex Actualtests "I purchase unlimited access in March 2016, on 7/19/17 i tried to access the new A+ exam to prepare myself and I had access to nothing. I reached out to..." Read more Aarons - Horrible absolutely unprofessional Aarons " I am highly disappointed and upset by how extremely unprofessional this company has been to me! I am paying for services that don't work and they refuse to fix..." Read more Pepperfry  received wrong product and pepperfry is not ready to accept it back Pepperfry "Hi have order a clock "Black Iron 8 Inch Vintage Double Sided Station Wall Clock by Anantaran" (Sku: DE1370875-S-PM6126) (Order No is 303227277) which has WHITE inner background being displayed..." Read more